# fishtakes To fish or not to fish? > fishtakes.com: short, sourced takes on fish and seafood from all over the world, from the North Sea to the delicacies of every coast. For each species: is it a good choice, check the label, or best avoided? Every figure has a source. Last updated 18 November 2026. Successor of the Belgian concept site fisk.be. ## Key figures - 35.5% of 2,570 assessed fish stocks worldwide are overfished; 64.5% are fished sustainably (FAO, 2025). - In the mid-1970s about 10% of fish stocks were overfished (Our World in Data, based on FAO). - About 9.1 million tonnes of fish are discarded worldwide every year, 10.8% of the catch (Gilman et al., Scientific Reports, 2020). - In 2022 aquaculture produced 94.4 million tonnes of aquatic animals, 51% of the total; total fisheries and aquaculture production was 223.2 million tonnes (FAO, SOFIA 2024). - Per capita consumption of aquatic animal foods rose from 9.1 kg in 1961 to 20.7 kg in 2022 (FAO, SOFIA 2024). - The leading edges of marine species shift poleward by about 72 km per decade, against 6 km on land (Poloczanska et al., 2013). ## Fish guide ### Delicacies of the world - [Fugu (tiger puffer)](https://fishtakes.com/fish/fugu/) (Japan): check the label. Eat fugu only in a restaurant with a licensed fugu chef: parts of the fish contain tetrodotoxin, a nerve poison with no antidote. The tiger puffer is listed as near threatened, so farmed fugu is the better choice. - [Japanese eel](https://fishtakes.com/fish/japanese-eel/) (Japan, China, Korea): best avoided. The Japanese eel is listed as endangered by the IUCN. Eel cannot be bred commercially, so every farmed eel starts as a wild glass eel caught at the coast. Unagi is best avoided until the stock recovers. - [Snow crab](https://fishtakes.com/fish/snow-crab/) (Japan, Canada): check the label. It depends on the origin. In the Bering Sea off Alaska, the snow crab stock collapsed after a marine heatwave and the fishery closed for two seasons. Canadian and Japanese fisheries are managed with quotas. Choose MSC-certified snow crab. - [Ayu (sweetfish)](https://fishtakes.com/fish/ayu/) (Japan): check the label. Ayu lives only one year and is a summer favourite in Japan, grilled whole on a skewer with salt. Most ayu on the market is farmed, and many rivers are restocked. The species is listed as data deficient by the IUCN. - [Beluga sturgeon](https://fishtakes.com/fish/beluga-sturgeon/) (Caspian Sea: Iran, Kazakhstan, Russia): best avoided. Wild beluga sturgeon is critically endangered, and international trade in its caviar is controlled under CITES. Buy only farmed caviar with a CITES label code on the tin, which shows the species, the source and the country. - [Greenland shark](https://fishtakes.com/fish/greenland-shark/) (Iceland): best avoided. The Greenland shark is the longest-living vertebrate known, with an estimated lifespan of several centuries, and it is listed as vulnerable. Hákarl is mostly made from sharks caught as bycatch. Try it once if you must, but do not make it a habit. - [Japanese sea cucumber](https://fishtakes.com/fish/sea-cucumber/) (China, Japan, Korea): check the label. The Japanese sea cucumber, the most prized species in China, is listed as endangered in the wild. Most of what is sold today is farmed in ponds and on the seabed in northern China. Choose farmed sea cucumber and avoid wild tropical species of unknown origin. - [Chinese mitten crab](https://fishtakes.com/fish/mitten-crab/) (China): check the label. In China, hairy crab is farmed in lakes and ponds and eaten in autumn for its golden roe. In Europe and North America the same crab is invasive and damages riverbanks. Buy farmed crabs from a trusted seller and check the tag on famous brands. - [Mandarin fish](https://fishtakes.com/fish/mandarin-fish/) (China): good choice. Mandarin fish is a freshwater predator from China, farmed in ponds on a large scale. It is listed as least concern by the IUCN. Farmed mandarin fish is a reasonable choice, and the famous squirrel fish of Suzhou is made with it. - [Humphead wrasse](https://fishtakes.com/fish/humphead-wrasse/) (Hong Kong, Southeast Asia): best avoided. No. The humphead wrasse is listed as endangered and is protected under CITES Appendix II. Demand for live reef fish in Hong Kong and southern China emptied many reefs. If you see it in a restaurant tank, choose another dish. - [Small yellow croaker](https://fishtakes.com/fish/yellow-croaker/) (South Korea, China): check the label. Small yellow croaker is one of the main fish of the Yellow and East China Seas, and it has been heavily fished for decades. Korea and China use closed seasons and minimum sizes. Eat it as a treat and ask where it was caught. - [Milkfish](https://fishtakes.com/fish/milkfish/) (Philippines, Taiwan, Indonesia): good choice. Milkfish is a good choice. It is farmed in brackish ponds and sea pens in the Philippines, Indonesia and Taiwan, and feeds low in the food chain. Watch for overcrowded fish pens, which can cause fish kills in lakes and bays. - [Giant river prawn](https://fishtakes.com/fish/giant-river-prawn/) (Thailand, Southeast Asia): good choice. The giant river prawn is farmed in freshwater ponds in Thailand, Bangladesh, India and China. It is listed as least concern. Pond-farmed river prawns are a fair choice and do not replace mangroves the way some sea prawn farms did. - [Mud crab](https://fishtakes.com/fish/mud-crab/) (Singapore, Indo-Pacific): check the label. Mud crabs are caught in mangroves across the Indo-Pacific, and many populations are heavily fished. Some are fattened or farmed in ponds. Ask where the crab comes from and avoid very small or egg-bearing females. - [Hilsa](https://fishtakes.com/fish/hilsa/) (Bangladesh, India): check the label. Hilsa is the national fish of Bangladesh, which lands most of the world's catch. Catches recovered after Bangladesh began banning fishing during the October spawning season and protecting young fish, called jatka. Eat hilsa outside the ban, never jatka. - [Bombay duck](https://fishtakes.com/fish/bombay-duck/) (India (Mumbai)): check the label. Bombay duck is a small lizardfish caught off Mumbai and Gujarat. It is eaten fresh as fried bombil or sun-dried. Catches have declined and young fish are often caught, so eat it in season and avoid very small fish. - [Silver pomfret](https://fishtakes.com/fish/silver-pomfret/) (India, Kuwait, the Gulf): check the label. Silver pomfret is a prized table fish around the Arabian Sea, the Gulf and in India. In Kuwait, where it is called zubaidi, catches have fallen sharply over the decades. Choose larger fish from a managed fishery and eat it less often. - [Hamour (orange-spotted grouper)](https://fishtakes.com/fish/hamour/) (United Arab Emirates, the Gulf): best avoided. Wild hamour in the Gulf is heavily overfished, according to the Environment Agency of Abu Dhabi. The UAE has added seasonal bans and size limits. Choose farmed hamour, or local alternatives that are doing better. - [Bluefish (lüfer)](https://fishtakes.com/fish/bluefish/) (Turkey (Istanbul), USA): check the label. Bluefish is a fast-growing predator found in warm seas worldwide. In Turkey, many young fish are caught as çinekop before they can spawn, despite a minimum size. Choose large lüfer in autumn and skip the small ones. - [Baikal omul](https://fishtakes.com/fish/omul/) (Russia (Lake Baikal)): best avoided. Baikal omul lives only in Lake Baikal. After the stock dropped sharply, Russia banned commercial and recreational fishing for it from October 2017. Omul sold as wild Baikal fish is likely illegal. Skip it until the ban is lifted. - [Vendace](https://fishtakes.com/fish/vendace/) (Sweden, Finland): good choice. Vendace is a small whitefish of northern lakes and the Baltic Sea. Kalix löjrom from the Bothnian Bay was Sweden's first product with a protected designation of origin. The fishery is short, local and regulated, so it is a good choice. - [Red king crab](https://fishtakes.com/fish/red-king-crab/) (Norway, Russia, Alaska): good choice. Norwegian red king crab is a good choice. The crab was introduced to the Barents Sea in the 1960s and Norway manages it with a quota in the east and free fishing further west to stop it spreading. In Alaska, the fishery has been closed in bad years. - [Arctic char](https://fishtakes.com/fish/arctic-char/) (Iceland, Canada, Scandinavia): good choice. Farmed Arctic char is a good choice. Most of it comes from Iceland, where it is raised in tanks on land with geothermal and spring water. Wild char from Arctic lakes is caught in small, local fisheries. - [Brown crab](https://fishtakes.com/fish/brown-crab/) (United Kingdom, Ireland): check the label. Brown crab is caught with pots around Britain, Ireland and Norway. Some stocks are in good shape, others are fished too hard, and rules on size differ by area. Buy heavy crabs above the minimum size, preferably from a certified or well-managed fishery. - [European flat oyster](https://fishtakes.com/fish/flat-oyster/) (France, Ireland): check the label. The native flat oyster has lost most of its reefs in Europe to overharvesting and disease. What you eat is mostly farmed or from small regulated beds. Enjoy it as a rarity, in the cold months, and support farmers taking part in restoration. - [Red mullet](https://fishtakes.com/fish/red-mullet/) (France, Greece, Mediterranean): check the label. Striped red mullet is fished across the Mediterranean and the Northeast Atlantic. Many Mediterranean stocks are fished too hard, often by trawlers catching young fish. Choose larger fish, preferably caught with nets or lines by small boats. - [Red scorpionfish](https://fishtakes.com/fish/scorpionfish/) (France (Marseille)): check the label. Red scorpionfish is caught in small numbers along rocky Mediterranean coasts, mostly by small boats. There is little data on the stock. Eat it as part of a proper bouillabaisse, made with local rockfish from small-scale fishers. - [Purple sea urchin](https://fishtakes.com/fish/sea-urchin/) (Italy, France): check the label. The purple sea urchin is harvested by hand in the Mediterranean and the Atlantic for its orange roe. In parts of Italy, demand emptied the rocks, and regions limited or stopped the harvest. Eat urchin only in season and from licensed fishers. - [Flathead grey mullet](https://fishtakes.com/fish/grey-mullet/) (Italy (Sardinia), Taiwan, Egypt): good choice. The flathead grey mullet is found in coastal waters worldwide and is listed as least concern. It eats algae and detritus and is also farmed in Egypt. Mullet and its roe, bottarga, are a good choice, though much bottarga uses imported roe. - [Mediterranean green crab](https://fishtakes.com/fish/moeche/) (Italy (Venice)): good choice. Moeche are Mediterranean green crabs caught in the Venice lagoon just after moulting, when the shell is soft. The fishery is small and traditional, and is supported by a Slow Food Presidium. A good choice in spring and autumn. - [Goose barnacle (percebes)](https://fishtakes.com/fish/percebes/) (Spain, Portugal): check the label. Goose barnacles are picked by hand from rocks in heavy surf. In Galicia, only licensed percebeiros may harvest them, with daily limits and closed areas. Buy percebes from regulated Galician or Portuguese fisheries, not from poachers. - [Atlantic bluefin tuna](https://fishtakes.com/fish/bluefin-tuna/) (Spain, Japan, Mediterranean): check the label. Atlantic bluefin tuna was heavily overfished until 2007, when a strict recovery plan began. The eastern stock recovered, and in 2021 the IUCN moved it to least concern. Choose traceable bluefin, from almadraba traps or fisheries with catch documents. - [Albacore (bonito del norte)](https://fishtakes.com/fish/albacore/) (Spain (Basque Country)): good choice. Albacore from the North Atlantic is in good shape. In the Bay of Biscay, Basque and Cantabrian boats catch it with poles and trolling lines, one fish at a time, with almost no bycatch. Pole-and-line or troll-caught albacore is a good choice. - [Common octopus](https://fishtakes.com/fish/octopus/) (Spain, Portugal, Greece): check the label. Common octopus is caught with pots, traps and trawls from Spain to West Africa. Some fisheries are well managed, such as the MSC-certified octopus of western Asturias. Choose pot-caught octopus with a clear origin; plans to farm octopus raise welfare concerns. - [Sea lamprey](https://fishtakes.com/fish/lamprey/) (Portugal, France): check the label. Sea lamprey is a jawless fish that is listed as least concern worldwide, but its spawning runs in Europe have declined because of dams and pollution. Eat it rarely, from regulated river fisheries in Portugal or France. - [Black scabbardfish](https://fishtakes.com/fish/black-scabbardfish/) (Portugal (Madeira)): check the label. Black scabbardfish lives at depths of 600 metres and more and is caught with longlines by Madeiran and Portuguese fishers. Deep-sea fish grow slowly, and stock data are limited. Madeira's longline fishery is small and selective; eat espada there, in moderation. - [White grouper (thiof)](https://fishtakes.com/fish/thiof/) (Senegal): best avoided. The white grouper, thiof, was the fish of Senegal's national dish, but heavy fishing made it rare and expensive. It is listed as near threatened. Many cooks now use other fish in thiéboudienne, and that is the better choice. - [Chambo](https://fishtakes.com/fish/chambo/) (Malawi): best avoided. Chambo is a group of tilapia species found only in Lake Malawi and nearby lakes. Catches collapsed after decades of heavy fishing, and the main species are on the IUCN Red List as threatened. Farmed chambo is starting to replace wild fish. - [Snoek](https://fishtakes.com/fish/snoek/) (South Africa): good choice. Snoek is a fast-growing fish of southern African and Australian waters, caught mostly with handlines. South Africa's seafood guide SASSI lists it as a green, good choice. Buy line-caught snoek from the Cape. - [Perlemoen abalone](https://fishtakes.com/fish/perlemoen/) (South Africa): best avoided. Wild South African abalone has been devastated by poaching linked to organised crime, and the legal wild fishery is very small. SASSI lists wild perlemoen as red. Farmed abalone from South Africa is the responsible choice. - [Bonga shad](https://fishtakes.com/fish/bonga/) (Nigeria, Senegal, West Africa): check the label. Bonga is a small fish that feeds millions of people in West Africa, mostly smoked. Catches are under pressure, partly because fishmeal and fish oil factories buy it for animal feed abroad. Eat bonga as local food, and question fish oil and fishmeal made from it. - [American lobster](https://fishtakes.com/fish/american-lobster/) (Canada, USA (Maine)): check the label. American lobster is abundant and caught with traps. The concern is the North Atlantic right whale, which gets entangled in trap ropes. Some Canadian lobster fisheries carry the MSC label; ask for lobster from areas using whale-safe measures. - [Sockeye salmon](https://fishtakes.com/fish/sockeye-salmon/) (USA (Alaska), Canada): good choice. Wild Alaskan sockeye salmon is a good choice. Alaska manages each run so enough fish reach the spawning grounds, and its salmon fisheries carry the MSC label. Bristol Bay has the largest sockeye run in the world. - [Geoduck](https://fishtakes.com/fish/geoduck/) (USA, Canada, China): good choice. Geoduck is the largest burrowing clam in the world, living for over a century. Washington and British Columbia manage the wild harvest by divers with strict quotas, and geoduck is also farmed. It is a good choice, and most is exported live to China. - [Red swamp crayfish](https://fishtakes.com/fish/crawfish/) (USA (Louisiana), China): good choice. Louisiana crawfish is farmed in rice fields between rice crops and caught in nearby swamps. It is a good choice. Elsewhere, in Europe and Africa, the same species is invasive, and eating locally caught crayfish helps control it. - [Atlantic blue crab](https://fishtakes.com/fish/blue-crab/) (USA (Chesapeake Bay), Italy): good choice. In the Chesapeake Bay, blue crab is managed by Maryland and Virginia with catch limits and protections for females. In the Mediterranean it is invasive and eats clams and young fish, so eating it there helps. A good choice in both places. - [Caribbean spiny lobster](https://fishtakes.com/fish/spiny-lobster/) (Bahamas, Cuba, Caribbean): check the label. It depends on the country. The Bahamas spiny lobster fishery has carried the MSC label, and most countries close the season during breeding. Elsewhere, undersized lobsters and illegal fishing are common. Buy lobster in season, above the legal size. - [Queen conch](https://fishtakes.com/fish/queen-conch/) (Bahamas, Caribbean): best avoided. Queen conch is declining across the Caribbean because too many young conch are taken. It is listed under CITES Appendix II, and many places limit or ban the catch. Eat conch rarely, and only from a fishery with size limits. - [Red lionfish](https://fishtakes.com/fish/lionfish/) (Caribbean, Florida): good choice. Yes. Red lionfish is native to the Indo-Pacific but invaded the Western Atlantic, the Caribbean and the Gulf of Mexico, where it eats young reef fish. Spearing and eating lionfish helps reefs. The spines are venomous, the meat is safe and tasty. - [Mexican four-eyed octopus](https://fishtakes.com/fish/maya-octopus/) (Mexico (Yucatán)): check the label. Octopus maya lives only on the Yucatán shelf of Mexico. It is caught in a short season with a traditional method, gareteo, using drifting boats and lines without hooks. Choose it in season, from the legal fishery. - [Fine flounder (lenguado)](https://fishtakes.com/fish/lenguado/) (Peru, Chile): check the label. Fine flounder is caught by small-scale fishers along Peru and Chile and prized for ceviche. There is little stock data, and young fish are often sold. Ask for larger fish, or try ceviche with other local fish, which is just as Peruvian. - [Black ark clam (concha negra)](https://fishtakes.com/fish/concha-negra/) (Ecuador, Peru, Colombia): check the label. Black ark clams are dug by hand in mangrove mud, mostly by women and children. Overharvesting and the clearing of mangroves for shrimp farms have reduced them. Ecuador sets a minimum size and closed seasons. Eat concha negra only of legal size. - [Arapaima (pirarucu)](https://fishtakes.com/fish/arapaima/) (Brazil, Peru (Amazon)): check the label. Arapaima breathes air and was easy to harpoon, so it vanished from many Amazon rivers. Community-managed fisheries in Brazil, which count the fish before setting a quota, brought it back. Choose pirarucu from managed lakes or farms. - [Argentine red shrimp](https://fishtakes.com/fish/argentine-red-shrimp/) (Argentina): check the label. Argentine red shrimp is wild, abundant and caught by trawlers off Patagonia. The main concern is bycatch of young hake and seabirds. Choose shrimp from fisheries with a fishery improvement project or the MSC label. - [Patagonian toothfish](https://fishtakes.com/fish/toothfish/) (Chile, Southern Ocean): check the label. Patagonian toothfish was heavily fished illegally in the 1990s and 2000s. Strict controls under CCAMLR cut illegal catches, and several fisheries now carry the MSC label. Choose MSC-certified toothfish only. - [Western rock lobster](https://fishtakes.com/fish/western-rock-lobster/) (Australia): good choice. Western rock lobster is a good choice. The Western Australian fishery became the first in the world to be certified by the MSC, in 2000, and it is managed with individual catch quotas and pot limits. - [Green-lipped mussel](https://fishtakes.com/fish/green-lipped-mussel/) (New Zealand): good choice. Green-lipped mussels are a very good choice. They are farmed on long lines in clean bays of New Zealand and need no feed, filtering plankton from the water. They are sold fresh in New Zealand and frozen on the half shell abroad. - [Coconut crab](https://fishtakes.com/fish/coconut-crab/) (Vanuatu, Pacific islands): best avoided. The coconut crab is the largest land-living arthropod, can live for decades and is listed as vulnerable. Island communities eat it, and tourists drive demand in restaurants. Leave it off the menu as a visitor, so local stocks last. - [Mahi-mahi](https://fishtakes.com/fish/mahi-mahi/) (Hawaii, Costa Rica, Peru): check the label. Mahi-mahi grows very fast and breeds young, which helps it cope with fishing. The concern is the method: longlines can catch turtles, sharks and seabirds. Choose troll or pole-caught mahi-mahi, or fish from US waters. ### Europe's favourites - [Salmon](https://fishtakes.com/fish/salmon/) (Norway, Scotland (farmed)): check the label. Salmon in Belgian shops is almost always farmed. It makes up 43% of the fresh fish Belgians buy for home. Choose salmon with a farming label such as ASC and check the packaging for the country of origin. - [Cod](https://fishtakes.com/fish/cod/) (North Sea, Norway, Iceland): best avoided. Cod from the southern North Sea, the stock closest to our coast, is below the safe limit of 14 million kilos. So check the label for the catch area and choose MSC-certified cod from a healthy stock. - [Dover sole](https://fishtakes.com/fish/dover-sole/) (North Sea (Belgium)): good choice. Dover sole is the most important fish for the Belgian fleet: in 2025 it accounted for 2,000 tonnes and 40% of the value of landings. The North Sea sole stock is above the sustainability target. North Sea sole is therefore a good choice. - [Tuna](https://fishtakes.com/fish/tuna/) (Tropical oceans (canned)): check the label. Tinned tuna is usually skipjack, a wild species that comes mainly from the Pacific Ocean. Choose tuna with an MSC label, preferably caught by pole and line. Yellowfin tuna from the Indian Ocean is overfished. - [Herring](https://fishtakes.com/fish/herring/) (North Sea, Netherlands): good choice. Herring from the North Sea is a good choice. The stock is above the sustainability target and ICES advises a substantial increase in the catch for 2027. Herring is also an oily fish, and eating oily fish regularly is recommended. ### North Sea fish - [Plaice](https://fishtakes.com/fish/plaice/) (North Sea (Belgium)): good choice. Plaice, called pladijs in Flanders, is a wild flatfish from the North Sea. The stock is well above the sustainability target and Belgian fishers land it themselves. That makes plaice one of the best choices at the fishmonger. - [Whiting](https://fishtakes.com/fish/whiting/) (North Sea (Belgium)): good choice. Whiting is a wild white fish from the cod family. The stock in the North Sea and the eastern Channel is well above the sustainability target. So choose whiting from the North Sea. Whiting from the Irish Sea and the Celtic Sea is best avoided. - [Haddock](https://fishtakes.com/fish/haddock/) (North Sea, Scotland): check the label. Haddock is a wild fish from the cod family. The North Sea stock is healthy, but ICES advises almost a fifth less catch for 2027. The state of the stock varies greatly by catch area. So always ask where your haddock was caught. - [Monkfish](https://fishtakes.com/fish/monkfish/) (North Sea, Northeast Atlantic): check the label. Monkfish, also called lotte, is a wild fish landed by Belgian fishers, worth 5.9 million euros in 2025. The state of the stock varies by catch area. So ask where your monkfish was caught. - [Skate](https://fishtakes.com/fish/skate/) (North Sea (Belgium)): check the label. Skate is a collective name for several cartilaginous fish. Thornback ray, blonde ray and spotted ray from the North Sea are above the sustainability target. Other species, such as starry ray and common skate, have collapsed. So ask which species you are buying and where it was caught. - [Turbot](https://fishtakes.com/fish/turbot/) (North Sea (Belgium)): good choice. Turbot is a flatfish from the North Sea that is also farmed. The wild North Sea stock is above the sustainability target and ICES is raising its catch advice for 2027 by 18%. Wild North Sea turbot is therefore a good choice, preferably outside the spawning season. - [Brill](https://fishtakes.com/fish/brill/) (North Sea (Belgium)): good choice. Brill is a wild flatfish that closely resembles turbot. The stock in the North Sea and the Channel is above the sustainability target and fishing pressure has been low for years. That makes brill a good choice, and it is often cheaper than turbot. - [Sea bass](https://fishtakes.com/fish/sea-bass/) (Europe (wild and farmed)): good choice. Sea bass in the shop is usually farmed, mainly in Greece and Turkey. If so, choose an ASC label. The wild stock in the North Sea and the Channel is growing and is above the sustainability target. For wild sea bass, choose line-caught fish. - [Lesser spotted dogfish](https://fishtakes.com/fish/dogfish/) (North Sea, English Channel): best avoided. Lesser spotted dogfish is a small shark from the North Sea that is often sold as zeepaling. The stock is growing, but fishing pressure is above the sustainable level and data are limited. So eat dogfish in moderation and ask which species you are buying. - [Tub gurnard](https://fishtakes.com/fish/tub-gurnard/) (North Sea, English Channel): best avoided. Tub gurnard is a wild bottom-dwelling fish with firm white flesh, usually caught as bycatch. The state of the stock is unknown, because scientists do not monitor tub gurnard separately. The Belgian seafood guide (Zeevruchtengids) therefore advises eating it in moderation. - [Lemon sole](https://fishtakes.com/fish/lemon-sole/) (North Sea): good choice. Lemon sole is a wild flatfish from the North Sea and the eastern Channel. Fishing pressure is below the sustainable level and the stock is above the safety threshold. ICES is raising its catch advice for 2027 by 20%. Lemon sole is therefore a good choice. - [Hake](https://fishtakes.com/fish/hake/) (Northeast Atlantic, Spain): good choice. Hake is a wild fish from the Northeast Atlantic and the Mediterranean. The northern stock is above the safe limit, while hake from the Mediterranean is overfished. So choose northern hake, preferably with an MSC label. - [Pouting](https://fishtakes.com/fish/pouting/) (North Sea (Belgium)): best avoided. Pouting is a small, wild white fish from the cod family. There is no quota and the stock is not scientifically monitored, so its state is unknown. The Belgian seafood guide (Zeevruchtengids) advises eating pouting in moderation, preferably line-caught. - [Dab](https://fishtakes.com/fish/dab/) (North Sea (Belgium)): best avoided. Eat dab in moderation. The North Sea stock is in good shape, but dab is mainly bycatch in bottom fishing and a lot of it is discarded. Choose fish longer than 27 cm and skip the spawning season, from January to June. - [Mackerel](https://fishtakes.com/fish/mackerel/) (Northeast Atlantic): best avoided. Atlantic mackerel is overfished. In 2025 the spawning stock fell below the critical limit Blim and ICES advised 70% less catch. The Dutch VISwijzer has rated mackerel red since April 2025. Only inshore mackerel caught by handline scores green. - [Sprat](https://fishtakes.com/fish/sprat/) (North Sea, Baltic Sea): check the label. It depends on the catch area. The sprat stock in the North Sea is above safe limits. In the Baltic Sea it is doing moderately, and west of Great Britain it is doing poorly. So ask where your sprat was caught. - [Flounder](https://fishtakes.com/fish/flounder/) (North Sea, Baltic Sea): check the label. Flounder is a wild flatfish that is landed mainly as bycatch of the flatfish fishery. The stock seems stable, but there is little data. Good Fish rates flounder from the Baltic Sea red. So ask where your flounder was caught. - [Atlantic wolffish](https://fishtakes.com/fish/wolffish/) (North Sea, Norway, Iceland): check the label. Atlantic wolffish from Iceland comes from a healthy stock. If you can, choose wolffish with the MSC label. Wolffish caught by longline, set nets or Danish seine is second choice. Good Fish rates trawl-caught wolffish red. - [Horse mackerel](https://fishtakes.com/fish/horse-mackerel/) (Northeast Atlantic): check the label. It depends on the catch area. The stock in the North Sea and the eastern Channel has been well below the desired level for more than ten years, and ICES again advises zero catch there for 2027. Choose horse mackerel from the Iberian coast. - [Grey gurnard](https://fishtakes.com/fish/grey-gurnard/) (North Sea): best avoided. Eat grey gurnard in moderation. It is mainly caught as bycatch and much of it goes back overboard. There is no catch limit and Good Fish rates grey gurnard from the North Sea red. If you do buy it, choose fish longer than 35 cm. - [Red gurnard](https://fishtakes.com/fish/red-gurnard/) (North Sea, English Channel): best avoided. Eat red gurnard in moderation. The state of the stock is unclear: there are no reference values and no catch limits. Good Fish rates red gurnard red, and the Belgian seafood guide (Zeevruchtengids) recommends eating it in moderation. Choose fish longer than 25 cm. - [Megrim](https://fishtakes.com/fish/megrim/) (North Sea, Northeast Atlantic): good choice. Megrim, called scharretong in Flanders, is a wild flatfish from the Atlantic Ocean. The stock west of Ireland and in the Bay of Biscay is healthy. That makes megrim a good choice at the fishmonger. ### Ocean fish of the world - [Yellowfin tuna](https://fishtakes.com/fish/yellowfin-tuna/) (Tropical oceans): check the label. It depends on the ocean and the method. Yellowfin in the Indian Ocean has been assessed as overfished, while Pacific and Atlantic stocks are in better shape. Choose pole-and-line or handline yellowfin, preferably with the MSC label. - [Bigeye tuna](https://fishtakes.com/fish/bigeye-tuna/) (Tropical oceans): check the label. Bigeye tuna is a slower-growing tuna than yellowfin and is caught by longlines for sashimi and by purse seiners as young fish. The Atlantic stock has been assessed as overfished. Choose bigeye from the Pacific, caught by Hawaiian longliners or with handlines. - [Pacific bluefin tuna](https://fishtakes.com/fish/pacific-bluefin/) (Japan, Mexico, North Pacific): best avoided. Pacific bluefin was fished down to a small fraction of its original size, mostly as young fish. Under a recovery plan by the Pacific tuna commissions it is growing again, but still far below historic levels. Keep it for rare occasions. - [Southern bluefin tuna](https://fishtakes.com/fish/southern-bluefin/) (Australia, Japan): best avoided. Southern bluefin tuna was heavily overfished and is listed as endangered by the IUCN. Under the CCSBT commission, catches are limited and the stock is slowly rebuilding. Eat it rarely; most goes to Japan as sashimi. - [Swordfish](https://fishtakes.com/fish/swordfish/) (Worldwide, Sicily): check the label. North Atlantic swordfish recovered after strict quotas in the 1990s and is in good shape. The Mediterranean stock is overfished. Choose harpoon or buoy-gear swordfish from the US or Canada, and be careful with mercury. - [Pacific cod](https://fishtakes.com/fish/pacific-cod/) (Alaska, Russia, Japan): good choice. Pacific cod from the Bering Sea and Aleutian Islands is well managed and MSC certified. In the Gulf of Alaska the stock fell after a marine heatwave and the fishery was closed for a season. Choose Alaskan cod caught with hook and line or pots. - [Chub mackerel](https://fishtakes.com/fish/chub-mackerel/) (Pacific: Japan, Chile, Peru): check the label. Chub mackerel is an abundant oily fish, listed as least concern. In the Northwest Pacific, catches by Japanese and Chinese fleets have been high and the stock has declined. Chilean and Peruvian chub mackerel is managed with quotas. - [Pacific saury](https://fishtakes.com/fish/pacific-saury/) (Japan, Taiwan, North Pacific): best avoided. Japanese catches of Pacific saury have collapsed since about 2015. Warmer seas pushed the fish far offshore, where fleets from China, Taiwan and Japan compete for it. The North Pacific Fisheries Commission cut quotas. Eat sanma rarely until it recovers. - [Pacific halibut](https://fishtakes.com/fish/pacific-halibut/) (Alaska, Canada): good choice. Pacific halibut is a good choice. The International Pacific Halibut Commission, founded by the US and Canada in 1923, sets catch limits each year. The fish is caught with longlines, and the stock is monitored closely. - [Greenland halibut](https://fishtakes.com/fish/greenland-halibut/) (Greenland, Norway, Canada): check the label. Greenland halibut lives in deep cold water around Greenland, Norway and Canada. Some fisheries, such as West Greenland and parts of Canada, carry the MSC label; others have no agreed quota. Choose certified Greenland halibut. - [Peruvian anchoveta](https://fishtakes.com/fish/anchoveta/) (Peru, Chile): check the label. Anchoveta is the largest single-species fishery in the world, managed by Peru with seasons and quotas. Most of it is turned into fishmeal and oil for fish farms and animals. Eating anchoveta directly, canned or salted, is a much better use. - [Capelin](https://fishtakes.com/fish/capelin/) (Iceland, Norway, Canada): check the label. Capelin is a key food for cod, seabirds and whales in the Arctic. Iceland, Norway and Canada set quotas from surveys and close the fishery in weak years, as Iceland did several times. Capelin and its roe are acceptable from these managed fisheries. - [Blue whiting](https://fishtakes.com/fish/blue-whiting/) (Northeast Atlantic): check the label. Blue whiting is abundant, but Norway, the EU, the Faroe Islands, Iceland, the UK and Russia have not agreed on how to share it, and together they catch more than ICES advises. Its MSC label was suspended in 2020 for that reason. - [Hoki](https://fishtakes.com/fish/hoki/) (New Zealand, Australia): good choice. Hoki from New Zealand is a good choice. The fishery has been MSC certified since 2001, with quotas based on yearly assessments. It is mild white fish, sold frozen as fillets and in fish fingers. - [Cape hake](https://fishtakes.com/fish/cape-hake/) (South Africa, Namibia): good choice. South African trawl-caught Cape hake has been MSC certified since 2004, one of the first fisheries in Africa with the label. Catches are limited by yearly quotas. It is a good choice. - [Argentine hake](https://fishtakes.com/fish/argentine-hake/) (Argentina, Uruguay): check the label. Argentine hake was heavily overfished in the late 1990s and early 2000s. Stricter limits helped the stock recover, but bycatch of young hake in the shrimp fishery remains a problem. Choose it from a certified or improvement fishery. - [Orange roughy](https://fishtakes.com/fish/orange-roughy/) (New Zealand, Australia): best avoided. Orange roughy can live for more than 150 years and reaches maturity only after decades. Many stocks were fished down quickly in the 1980s and 1990s, and bottom trawling on seamounts damaged deep-sea corals. It is best avoided. - [Common ling](https://fishtakes.com/fish/ling/) (Norway, Faroe Islands, Scotland): check the label. Common ling is caught mostly with longlines around Norway, the Faroe Islands, Iceland and Scotland. Stocks are generally in reasonable shape, but data are limited. Choose longline-caught ling from Norway or Iceland. - [Pollack](https://fishtakes.com/fish/pollack/) (Northeast Atlantic): best avoided. Pollack in the Celtic Sea and the Channel is in a poor state, and ICES advised zero commercial catch for several years. Leave pollack alone for now and choose other line-caught fish. - [John Dory](https://fishtakes.com/fish/john-dory/) (Europe, Australia, New Zealand): check the label. John Dory is mostly caught as bycatch by trawlers in Europe, Australia and New Zealand. There is little stock data and no quota in the EU. Enjoy it occasionally, ideally from New Zealand or a local small-scale fishery. - [Spiny dogfish](https://fishtakes.com/fish/spiny-dogfish/) (North Atlantic, North Pacific): check the label. Spiny dogfish grows slowly and gives birth to few young. In Europe the stock was overfished and the EU banned targeted fishing for a decade. The US Atlantic stock is managed and MSC certified. Choose US dogfish only. - [Blue shark](https://fishtakes.com/fish/blue-shark/) (Worldwide (Spain, Portugal fleets)): best avoided. Blue shark is caught in very large numbers on tuna and swordfish longlines, for its fins and meat. It is listed as near threatened and was added to CITES Appendix II in 2022. Shark meat is best avoided. - [Flying fish](https://fishtakes.com/fish/flying-fish/) (Barbados, Caribbean): good choice. Fourwing flying fish is caught by small boats around Barbados and the eastern Caribbean. It is fast-growing and abundant, though catches vary with sargassum seaweed and ocean conditions. In Barbados, it is a good local choice. - [Narrow-barred Spanish mackerel](https://fishtakes.com/fish/spanish-mackerel/) (Indian Ocean, Southeast Asia): check the label. Narrow-barred Spanish mackerel is popular from Oman and the Gulf to India, Southeast Asia and Australia. It is listed as near threatened, and stocks in the Gulf are overfished. Australian line-caught fish is managed with quotas. - [Indian mackerel](https://fishtakes.com/fish/indian-mackerel/) (India, Thailand, Indonesia): check the label. Indian mackerel is a small, fast-growing fish caught in large numbers across the Indian Ocean and Southeast Asia. It is listed as least concern, but some local stocks are heavily fished. Eat it, and choose fish of a good size. - [Indian oil sardine](https://fishtakes.com/fish/oil-sardine/) (India (Kerala), Oman): check the label. Indian oil sardine is a staple along India's west coast, especially in Kerala. Catches swing strongly with ocean temperatures and crashed in 2021 before recovering partly. Eat mathi, but avoid juvenile fish. - [South American pilchard](https://fishtakes.com/fish/pacific-sardine/) (Pacific: Mexico, Peru, Japan, South Africa): check the label. This sardine lives in the Pacific and off southern Africa, and its numbers boom and bust with ocean conditions. The US West Coast fishery has been closed since 2015 because the stock fell. Mexican and other managed sardines are a fair choice. - [Round sardinella](https://fishtakes.com/fish/round-sardinella/) (West Africa, Mediterranean): best avoided. Round sardinella is overexploited off Northwest Africa, according to FAO working groups. Industrial trawlers and fishmeal factories take a large share of a fish that millions of West Africans depend on for food. Avoid products made from it. - [Australasian snapper](https://fishtakes.com/fish/red-snapper-nz/) (New Zealand, Australia): check the label. Australasian snapper is managed under quotas in New Zealand and by states in Australia. Some stocks are healthy, others were so low that South Australia closed snapper fishing for several years. Ask where your snapper was caught. - [Sablefish (black cod)](https://fishtakes.com/fish/sablefish/) (Alaska, Canada, Japan): good choice. Sablefish from Alaska and British Columbia is a good choice. It is caught with longlines and pots under quotas and the stock has grown in recent years. It is famous for miso black cod. - [Wahoo](https://fishtakes.com/fish/wahoo/) (Caribbean, Hawaii, Indian Ocean): good choice. Wahoo grows fast and breeds early, which helps it handle fishing. It is caught mostly by trolling and recreational fishing, and as bycatch on longlines. Troll-caught wahoo is a good choice. - [Chinook salmon](https://fishtakes.com/fish/chinook-salmon/) (USA, Canada, New Zealand): check the label. Chinook salmon from Alaska is managed and partly MSC certified, but many runs in California, Oregon and Washington are listed as endangered or threatened. Choose Alaskan troll-caught king salmon, or New Zealand farmed king salmon. - [Chum salmon](https://fishtakes.com/fish/chum-salmon/) (Alaska, Russia, Japan): good choice. Chum salmon from Alaska is a good choice, managed by Alaska and MSC certified. Japan and Russia also catch large amounts, much of it from hatchery fish. Chum roe is sold as ikura. - [Pink salmon](https://fishtakes.com/fish/pink-salmon/) (Alaska, Russia): good choice. Pink salmon is the most abundant Pacific salmon and a good choice from Alaska, where it is MSC certified. Most is canned. In Norway and Scotland it has become an invasive species in rivers. ### Farmed and traded worldwide - [Alaska pollock](https://fishtakes.com/fish/alaska-pollock/) (Alaska, Russia (frozen)): check the label. Alaska pollock from the United States is a good choice. The stocks in the Gulf of Alaska and the eastern Bering Sea are healthy. Avoid pollock from the Russian Bering Sea. Check the pack for the catch area and the MSC label. - [Pangasius](https://fishtakes.com/fish/pangasius/) (Vietnam (farmed)): check the label. Pangasius is a farmed fish, mainly from the Mekong Delta in Vietnam. There are concerns about pollution and working conditions. Choose pangasius with the ASC label: Good Fish rates ASC pond farming green and cage farming red. - [Tilapia](https://fishtakes.com/fish/tilapia/) (Worldwide (farmed)): check the label. All tilapia on the European market is farmed. Tilapia needs little fishmeal, but ordinary farming pollutes the water and fish escape. Good Fish rates tilapia without a label red. So choose tilapia with the ASC label. - [Coley](https://fishtakes.com/fish/coley/) (North Sea, Norway): best avoided. Coley, also called saithe, is a wild fish from the Northeast Atlantic. North Sea coley lost its MSC label in June 2025 because of low productivity. So choose coley from the Faroe Islands, or in moderation from Iceland and the Northeast Arctic. - [Halibut](https://fishtakes.com/fish/halibut/) (Norway (wild and farmed)): check the label. Halibut is best eaten in moderation. In Belgium it is usually Greenland halibut. Choose MSC halibut, preferably caught with bottom longlines. Avoid Atlantic halibut from the Northeast Atlantic and Greenland halibut from the Barents Sea. - [Gilthead sea bream](https://fishtakes.com/fish/sea-bream/) (Mediterranean (farmed)): check the label. Gilthead sea bream, also sold as dorade, is almost always farmed: 98% of what Belgium imports is farmed. The biggest producers are Turkey and Greece. The Belgian seafood guide (Zeevruchtengids) says to check the farming conditions, so choose sea bream with the ASC label. - [Sardines](https://fishtakes.com/fish/sardines/) (Portugal, Spain, Morocco): check the label. Sardines are a good choice if they come from a healthy stock. Good Fish rates sardines from Morocco and MSC sardines from the Celtic Sea green. Avoid sardines from the Adriatic Sea, the Aegean Sea and the northern Bay of Biscay. - [Anchovies](https://fishtakes.com/fish/anchovies/) (Mediterranean, Bay of Biscay): check the label. Anchovies from the Bay of Biscay are a good choice: the stock recovered after the fishery was closed. Good Fish also rates some Mediterranean stocks green. Avoid anchovies from the Adriatic Sea and the south of the Iberian Peninsula. - [Nile perch](https://fishtakes.com/fish/nile-perch/) (Lake Victoria (Uganda, Tanzania, Kenya)): check the label. Nile perch, also sold as Victoria perch, is a wild fish from Lake Victoria. The Belgian seafood guide (Zeevruchtengids) advises against it because of overfishing and illegal fishing. Good Fish does rate catches with the Naturland label green. So only buy Nile perch with that label. - [Redfish](https://fishtakes.com/fish/redfish/) (Iceland, Norway): best avoided. You are better off leaving redfish alone. The fish grows slowly and only matures after ten years. Almost all stocks have collapsed and deep-sea redfish is rated red everywhere. If you do eat redfish, choose MSC redfish from Iceland, in moderation. - [Red snapper](https://fishtakes.com/fish/red-snapper/) (Gulf of Mexico, USA): best avoided. You are better off leaving red snapper alone. Good Fish rates all snapper red: snappers are overfished in many countries, the catch damages coral reefs and there is almost no management. Only wild red snapper from the US is strictly managed. - [Japanese amberjack (hamachi)](https://fishtakes.com/fish/yellowtail/) (Japan): check the label. Japanese amberjack is farmed in sea pens in southern Japan, mostly from young fish caught in the wild. The feed contains fish meal and oil. Farmed hamachi is acceptable as an occasional sushi fish; look for farms with hatchery-raised fish. - [Cobia](https://fishtakes.com/fish/cobia/) (Vietnam, Taiwan, Gulf of Mexico): check the label. Cobia grows very fast and is farmed in sea pens in Vietnam, Taiwan and China, and in offshore farms in Panama. Feed and pollution from coastal pens are concerns. Choose cobia from offshore or ASC-certified farms. - [Barramundi](https://fishtakes.com/fish/barramundi/) (Australia, Southeast Asia): good choice. Barramundi farmed in Australia, in ponds or recirculating tanks, is a good choice. Some Asian farms in open net pens have higher impacts. Wild barramundi is caught in northern Australia under state management. - [Meagre](https://fishtakes.com/fish/meagre/) (Spain, Greece, Turkey): good choice. Meagre is farmed in sea pens in Spain, Greece, Turkey and Egypt, and is a fair choice. It converts feed efficiently and is a good alternative to farmed sea bass and bream. Wild meagre is rarer. - [Large yellow croaker](https://fishtakes.com/fish/large-yellow-croaker/) (China): check the label. Wild large yellow croaker collapsed after intense fishing in the 1970s and 1980s. Today almost all of it is farmed in sea cages along the coast of Fujian, China. Farmed croaker is acceptable; avoid wild fish. - [Red seabream (madai)](https://fishtakes.com/fish/red-seabream/) (Japan, Korea): check the label. Most red seabream in Japan is farmed in sea pens, from hatchery fish, which is better than taking wild juveniles. Feed and pen pollution remain concerns. Farmed madai is acceptable; wild madai comes from managed coastal fisheries. - [Coho salmon](https://fishtakes.com/fish/coho-salmon/) (Chile, Alaska, Canada): check the label. Wild coho salmon from Alaska is well managed and a good choice. Most coho on the world market is farmed in Chile, where salmon farms use large amounts of antibiotics. Choose wild Alaskan coho or ASC-certified farmed fish. - [Siberian sturgeon](https://fishtakes.com/fish/siberian-sturgeon/) (China, France, Italy (farmed)): good choice. Siberian sturgeon is endangered in the wild, but it is the most farmed sturgeon and gives much of the world's caviar. Farmed caviar with a CITES code showing C for captive-bred is a good choice. - [Japanese sea bass](https://fishtakes.com/fish/japanese-seabass/) (China, Japan): check the label. Japanese sea bass is one of China's main farmed marine fish and is also caught wild around Japan. Farm practices vary widely. Choose farmed fish from a known producer, or line-caught wild suzuki. ### Freshwater fish - [Eel](https://fishtakes.com/fish/eel/) (Europe): best avoided. Better not. The European eel has been listed as Critically Endangered on the IUCN Red List since 2008. ICES advises zero catch for 2026. Farmed eel also comes from wild glass eels, so the Dutch VISwijzer rates all eel red. - [Trout](https://fishtakes.com/fish/trout/) (Europe (farmed)): check the label. It depends on where it was farmed. Rainbow trout from Northern Europe is rated green on the Dutch VISwijzer. From Western Europe, Poland and the United Kingdom it is second choice. Trout from Turkey or South America is best avoided. - [Salmon trout](https://fishtakes.com/fish/salmon-trout/) (Europe (farmed)): check the label. Salmon trout is not a separate species, but rainbow trout with pink flesh. It is sustainable if it comes from Northern Europe: there the Dutch VISwijzer rates it green. From Western Europe it is second choice, from Turkey or South America red. - [Zander](https://fishtakes.com/fish/zander/) (Europe (wild and farmed)): check the label. It depends on where it comes from. Farmed zander from recirculating systems and wild zander from Sweden, Estonia and Switzerland are rated green on the Dutch VISwijzer. Zander from Russia and Eastern European inland waters is overfished and rated red. - [Perch](https://fishtakes.com/fish/perch/) (Europe, Switzerland): check the label. Farmed perch from Western Europe is a good choice: the Dutch VISwijzer rates it green. Wild perch caught with fyke nets is second choice. Avoid perch from the Baltic Sea caught with gillnets, because the stocks there are under pressure. - [African catfish](https://fishtakes.com/fish/african-catfish/) (Netherlands, Belgium (farmed)): good choice. Farmed African catfish from Europe is a good choice. The Dutch VISwijzer rates farming in recirculating systems green. The feed contains little fishmeal and fish oil. Note that the European catfish is a different species. We found no rating for it. - [Carp](https://fishtakes.com/fish/carp/) (Central Europe (farmed)): good choice. Yes, farmed carp from Europe is a good choice. The Dutch VISwijzer rates it green. Carp grows in ponds and mainly eats grain, with hardly any ingredients from the sea. About 9% of European production is organic. - [Grass carp](https://fishtakes.com/fish/grass-carp/) (China): good choice. Grass carp is a good choice. It is one of the most farmed fish in the world, raised mainly in Chinese ponds, and it eats plants and grass rather than fishmeal. In North America it is an invasive species where it escaped. - [Silver carp](https://fishtakes.com/fish/silver-carp/) (China, USA (invasive)): good choice. Silver carp is a good choice. It is farmed in China on plankton, without feed, and in the United States it is an invasive species that harms native fish. Eating wild silver carp from the Mississippi basin, sold as copi, helps. - [Bighead carp](https://fishtakes.com/fish/bighead-carp/) (China): good choice. Bighead carp is a good choice. In China it is farmed on plankton without added feed, and its big head is prized for soup. In the US it is invasive and sold as copi to encourage people to eat it. - [Rohu](https://fishtakes.com/fish/rohu/) (India, Bangladesh): good choice. Rohu is a good choice. It is farmed in ponds in India and Bangladesh, often together with catla and mrigal, each feeding at a different depth. It needs little fishmeal. - [Catla](https://fishtakes.com/fish/catla/) (India, Bangladesh): good choice. Catla is a good choice. It is farmed in ponds in India and Bangladesh, where it feeds on plankton near the surface while rohu and mrigal feed lower down. It is listed as least concern. - [Crucian carp](https://fishtakes.com/fish/crucian-carp/) (China, Eastern Europe): good choice. Crucian carp is a hardy pond fish of Europe, listed as least concern, and is a fair choice. In Eastern Europe it is eaten fried in sour cream. In China, the related crucian carp, jiyu, is farmed in large numbers and used in milky fish soup. - [Wuchang bream](https://fishtakes.com/fish/wuchang-bream/) (China): good choice. Wuchang bream is farmed in ponds across China and eats mostly plants. It is listed as least concern and is a good choice. In Wuhan it is steamed whole with ginger and spring onion. - [Striped snakehead](https://fishtakes.com/fish/snakehead/) (Thailand, Vietnam, Indonesia): good choice. Striped snakehead is common in Southeast Asian rivers and rice fields, and is farmed widely. It is listed as least concern and is a fair choice. Outside Asia, snakeheads are invasive, so never release live fish. - [Channel catfish](https://fishtakes.com/fish/channel-catfish/) (USA (Mississippi)): good choice. US farmed channel catfish is a good choice. It is raised in earthen ponds in Mississippi, Alabama and Arkansas on a mostly plant-based feed. Imported catfish-like fish, such as pangasius, is a different species. - [Northern pike](https://fishtakes.com/fish/northern-pike/) (Europe, North America): good choice. Northern pike is widespread in lakes and rivers of Europe and North America and is listed as least concern. It is caught in small commercial fisheries and by anglers under local rules. Locally caught pike is a good choice. - [Walleye](https://fishtakes.com/fish/walleye/) (Canada, USA (Great Lakes)): good choice. Walleye is a good choice. Lake Erie has one of the largest walleye populations in the world, managed jointly by the US and Canada, and several Canadian lake fisheries carry the MSC label. Choose walleye from Lake Erie or a certified lake. - [Lake whitefish](https://fishtakes.com/fish/lake-whitefish/) (Canada, USA (Great Lakes)): check the label. Lake whitefish is caught in the Great Lakes and many Canadian lakes. Stocks in Lake Michigan and Lake Huron declined after invasive quagga and zebra mussels changed the food web. Choose whitefish from Lake Superior or certified Canadian lakes. - [Tambaqui](https://fishtakes.com/fish/tambaqui/) (Brazil (Amazon)): good choice. Wild tambaqui is listed as near threatened after heavy fishing of large fish in the Amazon. It is now Brazil's most farmed native fish, raised in ponds on mostly plant-based feed. Farmed tambaqui is a good choice. - [Murray cod](https://fishtakes.com/fish/murray-cod/) (Australia): check the label. Wild Murray cod is listed as vulnerable in Australia after decades of overfishing, river changes and cold-water releases from dams. There is no commercial wild fishery; the fish on menus is farmed. Choose farmed Murray cod. - [Asian swamp eel](https://fishtakes.com/fish/swamp-eel/) (China, Vietnam): check the label. The Asian swamp eel is common in rice fields and is listed as least concern. China farms it in net cages, often with wild-caught young. It is not a true eel and not endangered, but invasive outside Asia. A fair choice from known farms. - [Sterlet](https://fishtakes.com/fish/sturgeon-sterlet/) (Russia, Danube countries): check the label. Wild sterlet is listed as endangered by the IUCN because of dams, pollution and poaching. It matures quickly for a sturgeon, which makes it a popular farmed species for meat and caviar. Choose farmed sterlet only. - [Blue tilapia](https://fishtakes.com/fish/nile-tilapia-hybrid/) (Israel, USA, China): good choice. Blue tilapia is a hardy, mostly plant-eating fish farmed in ponds and tanks, often crossed with Nile tilapia. It is a good choice from responsible or ASC-certified farms. Released into the wild, it can become invasive. - [Wels catfish](https://fishtakes.com/fish/wels-catfish/) (Hungary, Spain, Eastern Europe): good choice. Wels catfish is a good choice. It is farmed in ponds in Central Europe, and in Spain, Italy and France it is an invasive giant that eats native fish. Eating wild wels from those rivers helps. - [Tench](https://fishtakes.com/fish/tench/) (Central Europe, Spain): good choice. Tench is farmed in ponds in Central Europe and Spain and is listed as least concern by the IUCN. Pond farming with carp needs little feed. It is a good local choice. - [Grayling](https://fishtakes.com/fish/grayling/) (Central and Northern Europe): check the label. Grayling needs clean, cold, fast rivers and has declined in many parts of Europe because of warming, dams and cormorants. It is protected in several countries and rarely sold. Leave wild grayling in the river; farmed grayling is rare. ### Shellfish, squid and crustaceans - [Mussels](https://fishtakes.com/fish/mussels/) (Netherlands (Zeeland), Belgium): check the label. Mussels in Belgium are almost always farmed, mainly in the Dutch Eastern Scheldt (Oosterschelde) and Wadden Sea. The season for Zeeland mussels usually runs from July to April. Choose farmed mussels with the MSC label, because the Belgian seafood guide (Zeevruchtengids) advises against wild mussels. - [Brown shrimp](https://fishtakes.com/fish/brown-shrimp/) (North Sea (Belgium)): best avoided. Brown shrimp are caught wild in the North Sea, but the stock is declining. In 2024 MSC described it as historically low, and the Belgian seafood guide (Zeevruchtengids) advises against them. So eat them in moderation and choose shrimp with the MSC label. - [Squid](https://fishtakes.com/fish/squid/) (Northeast Atlantic, Mediterranean): check the label. Squid, also sold as calamari, is best eaten in moderation. The stocks are poorly studied and there is no catch limit in Europe. Preferably choose squid caught with lines or lures. Avoid squid from the Mediterranean. - [Langoustines](https://fishtakes.com/fish/langoustines/) (North Sea, Scotland): check the label. It depends on where they were caught. Langoustines live in many separate stocks, and their condition varies. Choose langoustines with the MSC label or caught in creels. Good Fish rates trawl-caught langoustines from the North Sea and British waters red. - [King prawns](https://fishtakes.com/fish/king-prawns/) (India, Vietnam, Ecuador (farmed)): check the label. King prawns, sold in Belgium as scampi, are almost always farmed tropical prawns, such as whiteleg or tiger prawns. About 90% come from farms, mainly in India and Vietnam. Choose prawns with the ASC or an organic label and ask for the country of origin. - [Lobster](https://fishtakes.com/fish/lobster/) (Europe (Norway, Scotland, Brittany)): check the label. It depends on the species and the origin. European lobster from the English Channel is second choice on the Dutch VISwijzer. From Norway and the northern North Sea it is rated red. American lobster gets red because whales get entangled in the ropes. - [Pacific oyster](https://fishtakes.com/fish/pacific-oyster/) (France, China, Japan, Korea): good choice. Farmed Pacific oysters are a very good choice. They need no feed, filter plankton from the water and are grown in bags, on ropes or on the seabed. In northern Europe, wild Pacific oysters have spread and are now harvested too. - [Eastern oyster](https://fishtakes.com/fish/eastern-oyster/) (USA, Canada): good choice. Farmed Eastern oysters are a very good choice. They filter water and need no feed. Wild reefs in the Chesapeake Bay and elsewhere were overharvested, and restoration projects now rebuild them. - [Great scallop (coquille Saint-Jacques)](https://fishtakes.com/fish/great-scallop/) (France, UK): check the label. Great scallops from the Bay of Saint-Brieuc and Normandy are managed with short seasons and limits. Most are caught with dredges, which disturb the seabed. Hand-dived scallops are the best choice; well-managed French scallops are fair. - [Atlantic sea scallop](https://fishtakes.com/fish/sea-scallop/) (USA, Canada): good choice. Atlantic sea scallop from the US is a good choice. Managers close and reopen areas in rotation so beds can regrow, and the fishery is MSC certified. Canadian scallops are also managed with quotas. - [Japanese scallop](https://fishtakes.com/fish/yesso-scallop/) (Japan, China): good choice. Japanese scallop is a good choice. In Hokkaido, young scallops are seeded on the seabed and harvested years later, and the fishery carries the MSC label. Scallops on ropes in Mutsu Bay and China need no feed. - [Manila clam](https://fishtakes.com/fish/manila-clam/) (China, Italy, Japan): good choice. Farmed Manila clams are a good choice. They are seeded in sand and mud flats and filter their food. Italy, mostly the Po delta and Venice lagoon, is the largest producer in Europe. - [Common cockle](https://fishtakes.com/fish/cockle/) (UK, Ireland, Netherlands): good choice. Cockles are a good choice when hand-gathered from managed beds, such as the MSC-certified Burry Inlet in Wales. Mechanical dredging of cockles was banned in the Dutch Wadden Sea to protect birds and the seabed. - [Razor clam](https://fishtakes.com/fish/razor-clam/) (Spain, Scotland, Ireland): check the label. Razor clams are hand-dug or collected by divers, which is low impact. In Scotland, illegal electrofishing damaged some beds before a regulated trial was set up. Choose hand-gathered or diver-caught razor clams from licensed fishers. - [Mediterranean mussel](https://fishtakes.com/fish/med-mussel/) (Spain (Galicia), Italy): good choice. Farmed Mediterranean mussels are a very good choice. In Galicia they grow on ropes hanging from wooden rafts, bateas, in the rías, under a protected name. They need no feed and filter the water. - [Common whelk](https://fishtakes.com/fish/whelk/) (UK, Ireland, France): check the label. Whelks are caught in baited pots, with little bycatch. But whelks grow slowly, mature late and do not spread far, so local stocks can be fished out. Minimum sizes vary by area. Choose whelks from areas with size limits matching their maturity. - [Pacific abalone](https://fishtakes.com/fish/farmed-abalone/) (China, Korea (farmed)): good choice. Wild Pacific abalone is listed as endangered, but almost all of it on the market is farmed. Farms in China and Korea grow abalone in sea cages and feed them kelp. Farmed abalone is a good choice. - [Common cuttlefish](https://fishtakes.com/fish/cuttlefish/) (Europe, North Africa): check the label. Common cuttlefish grows fast and lives about two years, so stocks can recover quickly. Trawling can catch them before they spawn, while traps in spring take mostly adults. Choose trap-caught cuttlefish. - [Jumbo flying squid](https://fishtakes.com/fish/jumbo-squid/) (Peru, Chile, Mexico): check the label. Jumbo flying squid is abundant and grows fast, but hundreds of foreign squid vessels fish just outside Peru's and Argentina's waters with little control. Choose squid from Peruvian artisanal fishers or a fishery improvement project. - [Argentine shortfin squid](https://fishtakes.com/fish/illex-squid/) (Argentina, Falkland Islands): check the label. Shortfin squid lives one year, so catches depend on each year's recruitment. Argentina and the Falklands manage it with seasons, but foreign fleets fish on the high seas without limits. Choose squid from Argentina or the Falklands. - [Japanese flying squid](https://fishtakes.com/fish/japanese-squid/) (Japan, Korea, China): check the label. Japanese flying squid is listed as least concern, but Japanese catches fell sharply in the past decade, linked to changing sea temperatures and fishing by several countries. Eat it in moderation and prefer Japanese-caught squid under quota. - [Giant tiger prawn](https://fishtakes.com/fish/tiger-prawn/) (Vietnam, Bangladesh, India): check the label. Most tiger prawns are farmed, and shrimp farms have replaced large areas of mangrove forest in Asia. Wild tiger prawns are caught by trawlers with much bycatch. Choose ASC-certified or organic tiger prawns. - [Northern prawn](https://fishtakes.com/fish/northern-prawn/) (Greenland, Norway, Canada): good choice. Coldwater prawns from Greenland, Canada and Norway are a good choice. Most of these fisheries are MSC certified and use sorting grids that let fish escape. They are cooked and peeled on board. - [Gulf brown shrimp](https://fishtakes.com/fish/brown-shrimp-us/) (USA (Gulf of Mexico)): good choice. Wild brown shrimp from the US Gulf of Mexico is a reasonable choice. Trawlers must use turtle excluder devices, and seasons close to protect young shrimp. Bycatch of small fish remains an issue. - [Akiami paste shrimp](https://fishtakes.com/fish/akiami-shrimp/) (China, Korea, Southeast Asia): check the label. Akiami paste shrimp is one of the largest shrimp catches in the world by weight, mostly in China. It lives one year and breeds fast, but there is little stock data. It is a check-the-label product. - [Antarctic krill](https://fishtakes.com/fish/krill/) (Southern Ocean): check the label. Antarctic krill is very abundant and the catch is small compared to the stock. But fishing is concentrated near penguin colonies along the Antarctic Peninsula. Some fleets are MSC certified. Krill oil is optional for most people. - [Dungeness crab](https://fishtakes.com/fish/dungeness-crab/) (USA, Canada (Pacific coast)): good choice. Dungeness crab is a good choice. Fisheries from California to British Columbia keep only large males and release females, with closed seasons. Seasons are sometimes delayed to protect whales from trap lines or because of toxic algae. - [Gazami crab](https://fishtakes.com/fish/gazami-crab/) (China, Korea, Japan): check the label. Gazami, the Japanese swimming crab, is one of the largest crab fisheries in the world, mostly in China. Stocks are heavily fished and closed seasons apply. Eat it in moderation and choose larger crabs. - [European spider crab](https://fishtakes.com/fish/spider-crab/) (Spain, France, UK): check the label. Spider crab caught with pots in the Atlantic, from Brittany to Galicia, is a fair choice; scientists now treat it as its own species, Maja brachydactyla. The Mediterranean spider crab, Maja squinado, has become rare and is best avoided. - [Edible jellyfish](https://fishtakes.com/fish/jellyfish/) (China, Southeast Asia): good choice. Edible jellyfish is abundant and partly ranched in Chinese ponds. Jellyfish blooms are increasing in many seas. Eating it is a fair choice; the main concern is the use of alum in processing. - [Blue swimming crab](https://fishtakes.com/fish/blue-swimming-crab/) (Indonesia, Philippines, Thailand): check the label. Blue swimming crab is caught by small-scale fishers across Southeast Asia and sold as pasteurised crabmeat. Many stocks are heavily fished. Choose crabmeat from a fishery improvement project or MSC-certified source. - [Japanese mantis shrimp](https://fishtakes.com/fish/mantis-shrimp/) (Japan, China, Mediterranean): check the label. Japanese mantis shrimp is caught in coastal bays of Asia and the Mediterranean. In Tokyo Bay, catches collapsed and fishing was paused. Elsewhere it is common. Eat it in moderation from known fisheries. - [Banana prawn](https://fishtakes.com/fish/banana-prawn/) (Australia, Southeast Asia): good choice. Banana prawns from Australia's Northern Prawn Fishery are a good choice. The fishery is MSC certified and uses bycatch reduction devices. Prawns from Asian trawlers and farms are less certain. - [Sydney rock oyster](https://fishtakes.com/fish/sydney-rock-oyster/) (Australia): good choice. Farmed Sydney rock oysters are a good choice. They are grown in estuaries of New South Wales, need no feed and filter the water. Disease such as QX has hit some rivers, and breeding programmes help. ## Pages - [Home page with figures and frequently asked questions](https://fishtakes.com/) - [Fish guide, 201 species](https://fishtakes.com/fish/) ## Other languages - [Nederlands](https://fishtakes.com/nl/) · llms: https://fishtakes.com/nl/llms.txt - [Français](https://fishtakes.com/fr/) · llms: https://fishtakes.com/fr/llms.txt - [Deutsch](https://fishtakes.com/de/) · llms: https://fishtakes.com/de/llms.txt