- fishtakes
- fish guide
- black scabbardfish
Is black scabbardfish sustainable?
Short answer · deep sea: check
Black scabbardfish lives at depths of 600 metres and more and is caught with longlines by Madeiran and Portuguese fishers. Deep-sea fish grow slowly, and stock data are limited. Madeira's longline fishery is small and selective; eat espada there, in moderation.
Updated · Portugal (Madeira)
- Latin name
- Aphanopus carbo
- Wild or farmed
- Wild, deep-sea longline
- Where
- Portugal (Madeira, Sesimbra)
- Status
- Limited data, EU quotas
- Depth
- About 600 to 1,600 metres
three views
How to recognise black scabbardfish
How is the stock doing?
In Madeira, fishers have used longlines for black scabbardfish for centuries. The EU sets catch limits for deep-sea species. Bottom trawling for deep-sea fish was banned below 800 metres in EU waters in 2016.
What to look for when buying
Choose line-caught espada from Madeira or Sesimbra. Avoid deep-sea fish caught by bottom trawlers.
Black scabbardfish in Portugal
Espada com banana, fillets of black scabbardfish fried and served with fried banana, is Madeira's signature dish. At the Funchal market, the long black fish with large eyes is hard to miss.
Questions about black scabbardfish
Why is black scabbardfish black?
It lives in the deep, dark sea. Its skin is black, the flesh white and mild.
Is espada the same as swordfish?
No. Espada is the black scabbardfish. Swordfish is espadarte in Portuguese.
What is espada com banana?
Fried black scabbardfish fillets with fried banana, a Madeiran classic.
Sources
Consulted in October and November 2026.
More: delicacies of the world
- fugulicensed chef, farmed
- Japanese eelendangered
- snow crabcheck the origin
- ayumostly farmed or stocked
- beluga sturgeonwild: critically endangered
- Greenland sharkvulnerable, very slow
- Japanese sea cucumberchoose farmed
- Chinese mitten crabfarmed in China
- mandarin fishfarmed, least concern
- humphead wrasseendangered, CITES
- small yellow croakerheavily fished
- milkfishfarmed in ponds
- giant river prawnfarmed in ponds
- mud crabcheck the origin
- hilsarespect the ban
- Bombay duckcatches falling
- silver pomfretGulf stocks low
- hamourwild: overfished
- bluefishwatch the size
- Baikal omulfishing banned
- vendaceKalix: protected name
- red king crabNorway: managed
- arctic charfarmed: good choice
- brown crabcheck the area
- European flat oysterrare, mostly farmed
- red mulletMed: overfished
- red scorpionfishsmall catches
- purple sea urchinlimit the harvest
- flathead grey mulletleast concern
- Mediterranean green crabsmall lagoon catch
- goose barnacleGalicia: regulated
- Atlantic bluefin tunarecovered, strict quotas
- albacorepole and troll: good
- common octopuswild: check, avoid farmed
- sea lampreydeclining in Europe
- white groupernear threatened
- chambocollapsed, threatened
- snoekSASSI green
- perlemoen abalonewild: poached
- bonga shadpressure from fishmeal
- American lobstercheck the area
- sockeye salmonAlaska: well managed
- geoduckdive-caught or farmed
- red swamp crayfishfarmed in rice fields
- Atlantic blue crabinvasive in Europe
- Caribbean spiny lobstercheck the season
- queen conchCITES, declining
- red lionfisheat it: invasive
- Mexican four-eyed octopuslocal, seasonal
- fine flounderlocal catch, check size
- black ark clamrespect the size
- arapaimachoose managed
- Argentine red shrimpcheck bycatch
- Patagonian toothfishchoose MSC
- western rock lobsterfirst MSC fishery
- green-lipped musselfarmed: good choice
- coconut crabvulnerable
- mahi-mahiline-caught is better