fishtakesTo fish or not to fish?

  1. fishtakes
  2. fish guide
  3. South American pilchard

Is the Pacific sardine (pilchard) sustainable?

Short answer · California closed

This sardine lives in the Pacific and off southern Africa, and its numbers boom and bust with ocean conditions. The US West Coast fishery has been closed since 2015 because the stock fell. Mexican and other managed sardines are a fair choice.

Updated · Pacific: Mexico, Peru, Japan, South Africa

Latin name
Sardinops sagax
Wild or farmed
Wild
Where
Mexico, Peru, Japan, South Africa
Status
Boom and bust
Names
Pilchard, sardina, iwashi

three views

How to recognise South American pilchard

South American pilchard (Sardinops sagax) in side view: scientific illustration of the whole animal
Side view The whole animal: shape, fins and markings.
South American pilchard (Sardinops sagax) seen from the front: illustration
Front view What you see when it comes straight at you.
South American pilchard as it is sold at the fish counter: illustration
At the fishmonger How it is usually laid out on the counter.

How is the stock doing?

The collapse of California's sardine fishery in the 1940s inspired Steinbeck's Cannery Row. Today, managers stop fishing when the stock falls below a threshold.

What to look for when buying

Choose sardines from managed fisheries, canned or fresh. They are a good alternative to larger fish.

South American pilchard in Mexico

In South Africa, the Sardine Run along the KwaZulu-Natal coast each winter draws dolphins, sharks and crowds. In Japan, the same species is ma-iwashi.

Questions about South American pilchard

What is the Sardine Run?

A mass migration of sardines along South Africa's east coast in winter.

Why did the US close the sardine fishery?

The stock fell below the level where fishing is allowed.

Sources

  1. Wikipedia, Sardinops sagax
  2. FishBase, Sardinops sagax
  3. NOAA Fisheries, Pacific sardine

Consulted in October and November 2026.

More: ocean fish of the world

All 201 species in the fish guide